Investment Intelligence When it REALLY Matters.
Peter Schiff vs. Mike Stathis Scorecard: The Numbers Wall Street & Financial Media Don’t Want You to See
The Peter Schiff vs. Mike Stathis Scorecard (2006-2025)
The Numbers Wall Street & Financial Media Don’t Want You to See
THE HEADLINE
Twenty years of data are in.
Peter Schiff’s forecasting accuracy is 4–6%.
Mike Stathis’s is 82–90%.
This isn’t a debate.
This is a documented, forensic comparison of 100+ dated forecasts, scored using institutional accuracy standards.
THE REALITY
Schiff’s Record (2006–2025)
-
Hyperinflation calls? Wrong every time.
-
Dollar collapse? Never happened.
-
Treasury meltdown? Treasuries soared.
-
“Fed can’t hike”? Fed hiked 9 times.
-
Foreign stocks will outperform? They collapsed harder.
-
2009 rally “fake”? It was the generational bottom.
-
COVID crash worse than 2008? Fastest V-recovery in history.
-
2023 rally fake? New all-time highs.
Final Score: ~4–6% Accuracy
A non-functional model.
A decade and a half of being wrong in the same direction.
Stathis’s Record (2006–2025)
-
Called the housing crash with exact percentages.
-
Named failing institutions before they failed.
-
Predicted the 2009 bottom near Dow 6,500.
-
Navigated QE with precision.
-
Predicted COVID crash — and the bottom.
-
Predicted 2022 bear market — before it hit.
-
Predicted 2023 bull.
-
Called every major regime shift from 2006–2025.
Final Score: 82–90% Accuracy
One of the most accurate forecasters of the modern era.
Censored because he destroys narratives, conflicts, and money-making funnels.
THE DATA GAP IS NOT SMALL
| Metric | Schiff | Stathis |
|---|---|---|
| Institutional accuracy | 4–6% | 82–90% |
| Miss rate | ~94% | ~7–10% |
| Portfolio performance impact | Negative | Strongly positive |
| Record on major turning points | 0/12 | 12/12 |
WHY MEDIA PUSHES SCHIFF & HIDES STATHIS
-
Schiff sells fear, which sells gold, ad funnels, and media views.
-
Stathis exposes conflicts, pump networks, marketing pipelines, and fake experts.
-
Accuracy does not sell.
-
Fear always sells.
Schiff is the entertainer.
Stathis is the analyst.
THE 20-YEAR VERDICT
Schiff predicted the same collapse every year for 15 years.
Stathis predicted the right collapse at the right time — then predicted everything else.
Only one of them is a real forecaster.
And it’s not the one on TV.